Publikation:
Quantifying uncertainty: a practical comparison of Bayesian and frequentist meta-analytic frameworks applied to lead exposure and children’s IQ

dc.contributor.authorSell, Paulina
dc.contributor.authorSanchez, Margaux
dc.contributor.authorPalmont, Philippe
dc.contributor.authorSteiger, Simon
dc.contributor.authorPlaß, Dietrich
dc.date.issued2026
dc.description.abstractBackground Uncertainty quantification is central to evidence synthesis for risk assessment and policy-making. Frequentist meta-analysis - currently predominant in epidemiology - quantifies uncertainty through confidence intervals, while Bayesian meta-analysis provides posterior distributions. We performed frequentist and Bayesian meta-analyses to compare uncertainty quantification and applicability for risk assessment using lead exposure and children’s IQ as a case study. Methods We systematically searched PubMed and Scopus for epidemiological studies on blood lead level (BLL) and IQ score in children. After screening, risk of bias (RoB) in the identified studies was assessed and regression coefficients were harmonised to the scale. In both meta-analyses, we included the same effect estimates, assumed a multilevel structure and used random-effects models. The Bayesian meta-analysis employed a hierarchical model with weakly-informative priors. Sensitivity analyses examined robustness to RoB and prior specification. r2 and I2 were estimated as measures of between-study heterogeneity. Results Twelve studies were included in the meta-analysis. The frequentist model yielded a pooled estimate of -2.45 (95% confidence interval: -3.82 to -1.08) IQ points per unit increase in log e-transformed BLL (µg/dL) and a 95% predictive interval of -6.53 to 1.53. The Bayesian model yielded a mean pooled estimate of -2.28 (95% credible interval: -3.54 to -1.04) and a 95% predictive interval of -6.28 to 1.69. Between-study heterogeneity was substantial (frequentist: r2 = 3.32, I2 = 85.0%; Bayesian: posterior median r2 = 3.26, I2 = 84.7%). The Bayesian approach provided a full posterior distribution for heterogeneity, directly quantifying uncertainty from between-study variation. Sensitivity analyses showed both meta-analyses were robust to RoB, and Bayesian estimates were insensitive to tested priors. Depending on the specified prior configuration, the Bayesian model was less sensitive to studies reporting substantial uncertainty, resulting in a lower pooled effect compared to the frequentist model. This regularisation is particularly valuable in small meta-analyses, where frequentist heterogeneity estimates can be unstable. Conclusions We provide updated pooled estimates for the effect of lead on children’s IQ. The Bayesian framework provides posterior distributions, enabling direct probability statements, e.g. about exceeding risk thresholds, and comparative assessments between pollutants. These features are particularly valuable for risk assessment and policy-making.en
dc.identifier.doihttps://doi.org/10.60810/openumwelt-8917
dc.identifier.issn1471-2288
dc.identifier.urihttps://openumwelt.de/handle/123456789/12497
dc.language.isoen
dc.relation.isOrgUnitOfDeutschland, Umweltbundesamt, Fachgebiet II.1.6 - Expositionsschätzung, gesundheitsbezogene Indikatoren
dc.rights.urihttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
dc.subjectMeta-analysis
dc.subjectEvidence synthesis
dc.subjectBayesian modelling
dc.subjectUncertainty quantification
dc.subjectLead exposure
dc.subjectEnvironmental epidemiology
dc.subject.ddc500 Naturwissenschaften und Mathematik::500 Naturwissenschaften
dc.subject.ubaThemeGesundheit
dc.titleQuantifying uncertainty: a practical comparison of Bayesian and frequentist meta-analytic frameworks applied to lead exposure and children’s IQ
dc.typeWissenschaftlicher Artikel
dspace.entity.typePublication
local.accessRights.dnbfree
local.audienceWissenschaft
local.bibliographicCitation.journalTitleBMC Medical Research Methodology
local.bibliographicCitation.number26
local.bibliographicCitation.originalDOIhttps://doi.org/10.1186/s12874-026-03010-z
local.bibliographicCitation.pageEnd17
local.bibliographicCitation.pageStart1
local.bibliographicCitation.publisherPlaceLondon
local.bibliographicCitation.volume2026
local.reviewPeer-reviewed
local.versionTypehttp://purl.org/coar/version/c_970fb48d4fbd8a85
relation.isAuthorOfPublication4915ac78-a6a0-4d03-bfdd-fd05f723bbe0
relation.isAuthorOfPublication.latestForDiscovery4915ac78-a6a0-4d03-bfdd-fd05f723bbe0
relation.isOrgUnitOfPublication1dbe975b-80d3-4c09-b54e-d83557ed2ba1
relation.isOrgUnitOfPublication.latestForDiscovery1dbe975b-80d3-4c09-b54e-d83557ed2ba1

Dateien

Originalbündel

Gerade angezeigt 1 - 1 von 1
Lade...
Vorschaubild
Name:
2026-Quantifying uncertainty - a practical comparison of Bayesian and frequentist meta-analytic frameworks applied to lead exposure and childrens IQ.pdf
Größe:
2.97 MB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format

Lizenzbündel

Gerade angezeigt 1 - 1 von 1
Lade...
Vorschaubild
Name:
license.txt
Größe:
1.71 KB
Format:
Item-specific license agreed to upon submission
Beschreibung:

Sammlungen